Guest Post: Track Authorities Are Wrong To Ban Women With Naturally High Testosterone levels – Practical Ethics (blog)
Michael S. Dauber, MA
According to a story by Catherine Caruso published inSTAT Newsthis week, authorities at theInternational Association of Athletics Federations (IAAF)are getting set to debate whether or not women with hyperandrogenism, or higher-than-expected testosterone levels, should be restricted from competing against women with normal or expected levels. The debate over the IAAF rules began in 2011, when a rule was first created to prevent women with high testosterone levels competing because of the belief that their hormone levels gave them an unfair advantage. The rule was challenged in 2015, and the IAAF was given two years to provide further justification for its position.
As Caruso writes, the main focus of the current controversy is the legal case of Dutee Chand, an Indian athlete whose testosterone levels exceed the 10 nanomoles per liter limit, the level deemed to be the lower end of the male range, i.e., the amount of testosterone in the blood typically exhibited by male athletes. Testosterone is widely considered a hormone that assists in athletic performance, given that it increases the rate of muscle development and bone mass, among other traits. The idea behind the IAAFs position is that unnaturally high levels of testosterone that exceed levels typical of ones gender would give such athletes an unfair advantage over other competitiors. Insofar as the IAAF is concerned with creating the fairest competition possible, the presence of elevated testosterone levels in a select group of athletes, like Chand, presents a serious problem.
The problem with the IAAFs position, however, is that it overlooks one of the central nuances of sporting ethics. It is true that sporting events are supposed to be fair in a wide sense: we would not consider the competition just if one athlete took some action that made it impossible for other athletes to win. This is why athletes are given certain rules to which they must conform. In basketball, for example, one is forbidden from reaching out and grabbing the opposing players arm to prevent them from dribbling; in hockey, players are forbidden from tripping each other; and soccer players cannot decide to randomly touch the ball with their hands (unless, of course, they are a goalie).
Many athletes, regulatory bodies, and ethicists have also long believed that taking certain substances gives an unfair advantage to some competitors if the competition is not also allowed to take them. Two of the most common culprits are testosterone (the hormone for which Chand is in hot water) and human growth hormone (HGH), both of which can aid in athletic performance. Some have suggested that a simple solution might be to allow any athlete to take any substance they want: if there are no limits on what one can take, no substance could truly be considered unfair.
Yet many writers have expressed concern over this view, myself included. The essence of sport seems to be to push oneself to the limits of ones own capacities, to find what one is truly capable of. Bioethicist Maartje Schermer has written that in evaluating the fairness of advantages, rules, and enhancements in sports, we must ask ourselves What exactly do we want to praise or celebrate? In answer, he writes that According to the Presidents Council on Bioethics, what matters most is not even the competitive results but the specific type of human excellence displayed in a sport. This excellence may be thought of as a measurement of what we can naturally achieve through individual effort, which explains why we institute rules prohibiting the use of substances that enhance ones abilities beyond what one could naturally achieve.
The key to the debate over Chand and other athletes with naturally elevated testosterone levels is how we should define natural. While it is true that having an elevated testosterone level is unnatural in the sense that it is not considered typical of a human being of a specific gender, this fact alone does not seem to give an athlete an unfair advantage. If Chand and other athletes were choosing to inject themselves with testosterone to gain an advantage, they would have an unfair advantage because they were actively choosing to elevate their testosterone levels: they would be purposely trying to gain an edge. This conforms to the central criterion Schermer argues constitutes cheating: he writes that Actions that involve the breaking of implicit or unwritten rules and offer an unfair advantage constitute cheating, meaning one must act in order to cheat. For Chand and other athletes, this is simply not the case, and in that sense, they have not done anything unnatural or unfair. Their bodies simply work that way, and while their testosterone levels may not be typical of the average person, we do not normally restrict people from participating in sports just because they happen to be somewhat different than most people. There are many ways that athletes differ from the average person: this is what enables them to perform so well in the first place.
It seems that the IAAF is unfairly targeting a specific naturally-occuring advantage to the exclusion of others. Caruso writes that Georgiann Davis, a medical sociologist from the University of Nevada, has argued that the standards can seem very arbitrary, using the examples of very heavy sumo wrestlers and tall basketball players. Another helpful example might be athletes like Michael Phelps, whose attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) and unusual body shape may have given him more energy to train and unique advantages when moving through the water. While these elements gave him a significant advantage over his competition, he was not forbidden from competing because he did not purposely cause these things to occur.
There are certainly appropriate circumstances in which athletic federations are justified in restricting athletes from competing. Athletes like Chand have not purposely broken any rules or elevated their testosterone levels to gain an edge, so they should be allowed to compete.
Michael S. Dauber is a bioethicist who has served as a clinical ethicist and currently works as an institutional review board coordinator. He is also a visiting scholar at Global Bioethics Initiative. His masters thesis at NYU focused on the ethics of enhancement in doctors.
See more here:
Guest Post: Track Authorities Are Wrong To Ban Women With Naturally High Testosterone levels - Practical Ethics (blog)
- Suzanne Somers on Human Growth Hormone [Last Updated On: October 13th, 2014] [Originally Added On: October 13th, 2014]
- Around the NFL: League to start testing for human growth hormone [Last Updated On: October 13th, 2014] [Originally Added On: October 13th, 2014]
- Bodybuilding.com - Human Growth Hormone (HGH)! [Last Updated On: October 13th, 2014] [Originally Added On: October 13th, 2014]
- Human growth hormone (HGH): Does it slow aging? - Mayo Clinic [Last Updated On: October 13th, 2014] [Originally Added On: October 13th, 2014]
- Growth hormone - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia [Last Updated On: October 13th, 2014] [Originally Added On: October 13th, 2014]
- Human Growth Hormones Reviewed - HGH Supplements Revealed! [Last Updated On: October 14th, 2014] [Originally Added On: October 14th, 2014]
- What is HGH: Human Growth Hormone? - Video [Last Updated On: October 15th, 2014] [Originally Added On: October 15th, 2014]
- TACFIT Gable-Grip Suplex (100lbs Dummy) - Video [Last Updated On: October 21st, 2014] [Originally Added On: October 21st, 2014]
- Human Growth Hormone: Dr. Ferrari talks to Fox News about HGH - Video [Last Updated On: October 31st, 2014] [Originally Added On: October 31st, 2014]
- Human Growth Hormone Supplement.Natural HGH. - Video [Last Updated On: October 31st, 2014] [Originally Added On: October 31st, 2014]
- Comparing the Fed's QE3 to Taking Human Growth Hormone (HgH) - Video [Last Updated On: November 10th, 2014] [Originally Added On: November 10th, 2014]
- Global Human Growth Hormone Market 2015-2019 - Video [Last Updated On: November 21st, 2014] [Originally Added On: November 21st, 2014]
- Human Growth Hormone (645hz) - Video [Last Updated On: November 24th, 2014] [Originally Added On: November 24th, 2014]
- GenF20 Plus Human Growth Hormone Releaser 120-tablet | The #1 Rated HGH Supplements GenF20 plus.mp4 - Video [Last Updated On: November 25th, 2014] [Originally Added On: November 25th, 2014]
- 1.05 Hz ~ Releases Human Growth Hormone - Pure Binaural Beats - Video [Last Updated On: November 26th, 2014] [Originally Added On: November 26th, 2014]
- Genf20 Plus Reviews - A Breakthrough In Anti Aging - Video [Last Updated On: December 6th, 2014] [Originally Added On: December 6th, 2014]
- Where to get HGH and use it correctly - Video [Last Updated On: January 22nd, 2015] [Originally Added On: January 22nd, 2015]
- where to get legal steroids and hgh - Video [Last Updated On: January 22nd, 2015] [Originally Added On: January 22nd, 2015]
- Human Growth Hormone or HGH online transformation - Video [Last Updated On: January 22nd, 2015] [Originally Added On: January 22nd, 2015]
- Binaural Beats - Grow taller (human growth hormone) - Video [Last Updated On: January 29th, 2015] [Originally Added On: January 29th, 2015]
- Buy HGH Releaser GenF20 Plus 2013's Best Human Growth Hormone - Video [Last Updated On: February 10th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 10th, 2015]
- GH Advanced Reviews - Video [Last Updated On: February 16th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 16th, 2015]
- 1.05hz Frequency - Human Growth Hormone release meditation, Binaural beats and Isochronic beats - Video [Last Updated On: March 4th, 2015] [Originally Added On: March 4th, 2015]
- Global Human Growth Hormone Market Research Report 2015 - 2019 - Video [Last Updated On: March 5th, 2015] [Originally Added On: March 5th, 2015]
- Human Growth Hormone Hgh gen 20 plus - Video [Last Updated On: March 12th, 2015] [Originally Added On: March 12th, 2015]
- Human Growth Hormone Height Increase - Video [Last Updated On: March 12th, 2015] [Originally Added On: March 12th, 2015]
- Human Growth Hormone Market in US 2015-2019 - Video [Last Updated On: March 21st, 2015] [Originally Added On: March 21st, 2015]
- Fitness over 40 - Video [Last Updated On: March 24th, 2015] [Originally Added On: March 24th, 2015]
- JV & Elvis - Human Growth Hormone - Video [Last Updated On: April 11th, 2015] [Originally Added On: April 11th, 2015]
- Limitless THRIVE Video - Video [Last Updated On: April 18th, 2015] [Originally Added On: April 18th, 2015]
- HGH - Human Growth Hormone [Last Updated On: May 22nd, 2015] [Originally Added On: May 22nd, 2015]
- HGH - Human Growth Hormone :: Advice HGH [Last Updated On: May 22nd, 2015] [Originally Added On: May 22nd, 2015]
- Human Growth Hormone (HGH) - Top 3 Products on Review [Last Updated On: May 22nd, 2015] [Originally Added On: May 22nd, 2015]
- Human Growth Hormone Research - In-Depth Information [Last Updated On: May 27th, 2015] [Originally Added On: May 27th, 2015]
- Human Growth Hormone - Steroid .com [Last Updated On: May 31st, 2015] [Originally Added On: May 31st, 2015]
- The Top 3 Human Growth Hormone (HGH) Supplements Compared ... [Last Updated On: June 1st, 2015] [Originally Added On: June 1st, 2015]
- Human growth hormone facts | General center | SteadyHealth.com [Last Updated On: June 6th, 2015] [Originally Added On: June 6th, 2015]
- Human growth hormone facts | General center | SteadyHealth ... [Last Updated On: June 8th, 2015] [Originally Added On: June 8th, 2015]
- HGH, Buy Human Growth Hormone (HGH) Supplements Online [Last Updated On: July 4th, 2015] [Originally Added On: July 4th, 2015]
- Human Growth Hormone Therapy Men | AAG HealthGains [Last Updated On: July 11th, 2015] [Originally Added On: July 11th, 2015]
- Global Human Growth Hormone Market Report: 2015 Edition [Last Updated On: August 2nd, 2015] [Originally Added On: August 2nd, 2015]
- human growth hormone - WebMD [Last Updated On: August 2nd, 2015] [Originally Added On: August 2nd, 2015]
- Natural Growth Hormone Boosters | The Dr. Oz Show [Last Updated On: August 30th, 2015] [Originally Added On: August 30th, 2015]
- Human Growth Hormone Therapy For Women | HGH Therapy [Last Updated On: August 30th, 2015] [Originally Added On: August 30th, 2015]
- HGH FAQ - Human Growth Hormone [Last Updated On: August 30th, 2015] [Originally Added On: August 30th, 2015]
- HGH Human Growth Hormone | Buy HGH Injections | Hormone ... [Last Updated On: August 30th, 2015] [Originally Added On: August 30th, 2015]
- Injectable HGH Human Growth Hormone [Last Updated On: August 30th, 2015] [Originally Added On: August 30th, 2015]
- Human Growth Hormone - Mayo Clinic [Last Updated On: August 30th, 2015] [Originally Added On: August 30th, 2015]
- Human Growth Hormone - Muscle & Fitness [Last Updated On: August 30th, 2015] [Originally Added On: August 30th, 2015]
- Growth Hormone Articles! - Bodybuilding.com [Last Updated On: August 30th, 2015] [Originally Added On: August 30th, 2015]
- Human Growth Hormone (HGH) - Nutrition Express [Last Updated On: August 30th, 2015] [Originally Added On: August 30th, 2015]
- Global Human Growth Hormone Industry 2015 Market Research ... [Last Updated On: September 5th, 2015] [Originally Added On: September 5th, 2015]
- Human Growth Hormone Testing | Private MD Labs [Last Updated On: September 21st, 2015] [Originally Added On: September 21st, 2015]
- Human Growth Hormone (HGH) | Genemedics [Last Updated On: October 22nd, 2015] [Originally Added On: October 22nd, 2015]
- Human Growth Hormone | Worldhealth.net Anti-Aging News [Last Updated On: October 22nd, 2015] [Originally Added On: October 22nd, 2015]
- BodyLogicMD - Human Growth Hormone in men [Last Updated On: October 24th, 2015] [Originally Added On: October 24th, 2015]
- Growth hormone, athletic performance, and aging - Harvard ... [Last Updated On: October 30th, 2015] [Originally Added On: October 30th, 2015]
- Growth hormone. - National Center for Biotechnology Information [Last Updated On: August 22nd, 2016] [Originally Added On: August 22nd, 2016]
- Norditropin Growth Hormone Therapy [Last Updated On: August 24th, 2016] [Originally Added On: August 24th, 2016]
- hGH Human Growth Hormone - Natural hGH Supplement [Last Updated On: August 24th, 2016] [Originally Added On: August 24th, 2016]
- HGH definition - HGH for sale [Last Updated On: September 3rd, 2016] [Originally Added On: September 3rd, 2016]
- The Time Course of the Human Growth Hormone Response to a 6 s and a 30 ... [Last Updated On: September 8th, 2016] [Originally Added On: September 8th, 2016]
- Human growth hormone doping in sport - ncbi.nlm.nih.gov [Last Updated On: October 9th, 2016] [Originally Added On: October 9th, 2016]
- HGH for Sale | Buy Human Growth Hormone for Bodybuilding [Last Updated On: October 12th, 2016] [Originally Added On: October 12th, 2016]
- Global Human Growth Hormone Market Research Report 2016 [Last Updated On: October 16th, 2016] [Originally Added On: October 16th, 2016]
- The Time Course of the Human Growth Hormone Response to a 6 s ... [Last Updated On: October 26th, 2016] [Originally Added On: October 26th, 2016]
- Human growth hormone induces SOCS3 and CIS mRNA increase in ... [Last Updated On: November 1st, 2016] [Originally Added On: November 1st, 2016]
- Global Human Growth Hormone Market by Manufacturers, Regions ... [Last Updated On: November 1st, 2016] [Originally Added On: November 1st, 2016]
- Sprint 8 Exercises Increase Your "Fitness Hormone" Levels [Last Updated On: January 23rd, 2017] [Originally Added On: January 23rd, 2017]
- Credit Suisse Starts Ascendis Pharma (ASND) at Outperform - Economic Calendar [Last Updated On: February 11th, 2017] [Originally Added On: February 11th, 2017]
- Unproven IVF treatments add to the cost for infertile couples - The Northern Daily Leader [Last Updated On: February 18th, 2017] [Originally Added On: February 18th, 2017]
- The story behind human growth hormone - ZME Science [Last Updated On: February 18th, 2017] [Originally Added On: February 18th, 2017]
- Versartis Reports Fourth Quarter 2016 Financial Results - P&T Community [Last Updated On: February 22nd, 2017] [Originally Added On: February 22nd, 2017]
- Blog About Legit HGH Supplement Chosen by Athletes :: Luke ... - SportsBlog.com (blog) [Last Updated On: February 22nd, 2017] [Originally Added On: February 22nd, 2017]
- Animal steroids, growth hormone for bodybuilder's 'bad back': court - Braidwood Times [Last Updated On: February 26th, 2017] [Originally Added On: February 26th, 2017]
- Versartis to Present at Cowen & Co. Annual Healthcare Conference and Barclays Global Healthcare Conference - P&T Community [Last Updated On: March 2nd, 2017] [Originally Added On: March 2nd, 2017]
- Goold: Schafer bids to become baseball's 'Slash' - STLtoday.com [Last Updated On: March 4th, 2017] [Originally Added On: March 4th, 2017]
- Better Buy: Myriad Genetics, Inc. vs. Opko Health, Inc. - Madison.com [Last Updated On: March 11th, 2017] [Originally Added On: March 11th, 2017]
- Global Human Growth Hormone (HGH) Market Outlook 2022; New Report Launched - Digital Journal [Last Updated On: March 12th, 2017] [Originally Added On: March 12th, 2017]
- Doc in St. Louis County who prescribed illegal HGH can practice ... - STLtoday.com [Last Updated On: March 16th, 2017] [Originally Added On: March 16th, 2017]